[Moon] [Moon-net] wsjt-cw ... there is no debate.

[Peter Sundberg]

Brian, 

It is sad to note that you, as well as most Deep Search Evangelists, have
not grasped the fact that JT65 Deep Search NEVER communicates full
callsigns. Please read the JT65 tutorial on the WSJT webpage, and you will
see that this statement is correct.

CW communicates anything that is sent, at any level of S/N. A skilled
operator will copy at lower S/N than a not so skilled operator. 

Deep Search never COPIES calls.

Thanks Doug for pointing out that my "ARRL EME Contest" message had nothing
to do with CW vs digital, it was all focused on how the ARRL EME Contest
has collapsed into a dark hole. 

But I think the person I was pointing at in that message is very pleased
that the debate has turned into the good old CW vs digital feud, because
this has been his tactics ever since I started questioning the validity of
a "QSO" made by using Deep Search. And he has had good help from W9IP with
his "moderation ON" magic stick.

BTW, W7GJ can say Hallelujah! to JT65A Deep Search every week on Moon-Net
without comments, but when I say CW is King, I am a BAD and vicious person.. 

I love it. Because CW really IS King!

73 de Peter SM2CEW
www.sm2cew.com
http://blog.sm2cew.com











At 23:17 2008-04-16 , Brian Mullaney wrote:
>Doug McArthur wrote:
>> Hi Jonathan et al
>> Where .. just where has ANYONE stated that CW is better than WSJT in 
>> the recent postings.
>>
>>   
>Between SM2CEW saying "cw is king" every chance he gets and HB9BBD 
>saying that WSJT does nothing but
>"....."process" by simply picking callsigns from a file on the disk and 
>claiming a "QSO""
>
>Well, I don't know where anyone would get the idea that people are 
>stating that CW is better then WSJT
>
>As for me, I'll just get  back to wondering why its ok to have EME 
>callsign lists, but bad when it is on a computer.
>
>73
>Brian N2AET
>
>
>_______________________________________________
>Moon mailing list
>Moon at moonbounce.info
>http://www.moonbounce.info/mailman/listinfo/moon
>
> Please enter/update your standings: 
> http://www.vhf-dx.net/top.html
>
> When you decide to remain anonymous I may consider this unpolite and
remove you from the list
>